A page of analysis by Simon Gleave and Pier-Luigi, covering players performance and team tactics.
If you want to comment or make a point, you are invited to write to the supporters mailing list E-Goals. See the link at the foot of the page.!

Arsenal v Crystal Palace
21st February 1998
FA Premier League

Team : Miller, Edworthy, Smith, Gordon, Roberts, Hreidarsson, Ismael, Fullarton, Rodger, Dyer, Brolin
Subs : Nash, Tuttle(Dyer 77'), Emblen, Bent(Smith 67'), Linighan.
Booked :Dyer, Fullarton, Hreidarsson, Roberts

 

Match Reports & action photos.

the wrong attitude
Sometimes one guesses whether football games are prepared according to the name of the team you are playing against or according to the actual players of the team you are playing against.

Nine out of eleven players in the Arsenal line-up were reserves, some of them extremely green (Vernazza, Upson); compared to that, Crystal Palace's situation (four key players being absent), looked pretty rosy.

In spite of that, we approached the game as if we were playing against the likes of Bergkamp, Wright, Seaman, Overmars and Co., we were awed by Arsenal shirts more than by Arsenal players and consequently we sat back waiting for the opponents to attack us.

It's pretty clear to me that this tactic is not going to work, the best result you can get out of it is a scoreless draw and the chances that the opponents, piling up the pressure, will finally breach your rearguard are very high as it was sadly shown on Saturday.

o change for the better or for the worse?
Do you think that the changes made by Steve Coppell during the game were well thought trough or were desperation moves?

Bent for Smith: this was a reasonable substitution, at least on the paper. Smith was continuing his personal campaign to persuade any Crystal Palace supporter that they should regret the release of Kevin Muscat and therefore the sooner he was off the better. But why was Marcus Bent played as a wide midfield player and not as a striker? The player is still extremely naïve and immature, is often caught in possession and to lose the ball in midfield is way too dangerous than to lose it upfront. In addition to that, the number of crosses delivered by the former Brentford player (zero) is self-explanatory.

Tuttle upfront? Sure, Bruce Dyer was having the usual nightmare game, but to play a centre-back, who is incidentally out of action since September, as your main striker, is utterly ridiculous.

I believe that at this point in time the only alteration that would make sense and that would give a morale boost to a disheartened team is the change of the manager himself.
Steve Coppell is not completely responsible for the failure of the team, he has obviously had hard luck with the injuries, but he has made several bad mistakes and he has got to pay for them:

Crystal Palace are going down, we need extreme actions and we need them now.

Pier-Luigi Giganti

Pier's match Stats

 

KEVIN MILLER
An adequate performance in goal with very few saves to make. His distribution was better than of late and he had no chance with Grimandi's freak effort.

JAMIE SMITH
Didn't get forward enough although his only cross should have been converted. Defensively, he still has a lot to learn and we were certainly weaker down his flank than Gordon's.

VALERIEN ISMAEL
Made one atrocious mistake in the second half when failing to jump for a cross which left Platt with a free header. Still looks short of quality at this level but the system hardly helps him.

DEAN GORDON
A very good first half but like the rest of the team, he faded after the goal. Probably in his best spell of form of the season.

HERMAN HREIDARSSON
Didn't see much of him in this game as his famed runs failed to materialise and his defending was workmanlike but no more. Another whose influence faded after the goal.

ANDY ROBERTS
Another poor match. His passing was often awry and he failed to pick up umpteen runs from the Arsenal midfield. Roberts really is the major disappointment of the season.

MARC EDWORTHY
Another typical performance from Edworthy who was again the pick of the defenders. Solid tackling and sensible passing were the hallmarks of his performance.

JAMIE FULLARTON
One of his better games of the season as his tigerish tackling in midfield broke up a lot of the Arsenal midfield play. His passing really isn't good enough though and being a defensive midfielder, he was rarely in support of the attack.

TOMAS BROLIN
His pass to Smith in the first half was absolute genius but was given little opportunity to repeat this. It really is amazing that we fail to use a player of such undoubted skill and our tactics reduce him to nothing more than a peripheral performer in most games. Give him the ball at his feet and he'll make things happen.

SIMON RODGER
Good to have him back and his second half shot was our only real effort of the half. Frustrated by the lack of support when winning midfield possession.

BRUCE DYER
Woeful. His miss from 2 yards in the first half was a crime, particularly bearing in mind the quality of the play from Brolin and Smith which led up to it. Again caught offside regularly and rarely distributing the ball to players in better positions.

Subs

MARCUS BENT
Gave Palace some much needed pace when he came on but was playing in too deep a position to cause much trouble.

DAVID TUTTLE
A player who hadn't played for 5 months is thrown on up front. Barely touched the ball and looked extremely uncomfortable.

Man of the Match
SIMON RODGER was about the most influential player in a bland performance. His passing was good and he looked like the only player who believed we might equalise. The rest of the team (with the exception of Dyer and Roberts) didn't play too badly but they are given very little chance to express themselves in such a defensive system. To play this way against Arsenal's reserve team was to give them all the initiative and we got what we deserved. Absolutely nothing.

Simon Gleave

 

If you would like to reply or comment by e-mail, click here
The e-mail address is listserver@isfa.com

If you want to subscribe to the list, you can do this too, just click here.